The Tulpa She Had to Unmake
A lean-faced monk in a red robe smiles slyly in a lamp-lit tent, a bowl of butter before him, snowy Himalayan peaks in moonlight behind.
Passed Down

The Tulpa She Had to Unmake

As told by The Archivist · 3 min read · Published 11 November 2026

Alexandra David-Néel said that a short, fat monk once travelled with her party in the Himalayan borderlands. He kept pace with them, stopped now and then, and turned his head to look around like any traveller on a long road. She said she had made him herself, alone, over a few months, out of concentration and ritual.

She was a Frenchwoman in her middle years who spent much of the 1910s and early 1920s in Tibet and the Himalayan borderlands, learning Tibetan and studying with lamas. In her book, published in French in 1929 as Mystiques et magiciens du Tibet and in English in 1932 as Magic and Mystery in Tibet, she describes what the monks called tulpas, from the Tibetan sprul-pa, usually translated as a magical emanation: forms they said a trained mind could build through long, steady concentration. She was curious and she was doubtful, so she tried it. She chose something harmless on purpose, a short, chubby, cheerful monk, a jolly trapa of the kind she might pass on any road.

She shut herself away in tsams, a solitary retreat, and carried out, in her words, "the prescribed concentration of thought and other rites." After a few months, she wrote, the phantom monk was formed. His form grew "gradually fixed and life-like looking," and he became a kind of guest, living in her quarters.

Then she ended her seclusion and set off on a tour of the borderlands with her servants and her tents, and the monk included himself in the party. Her book does not say whether her servants ever saw him. She lived in the open and rode on horseback for miles each day, and he was still there. She no longer had to think of him to see him. He walked, he stopped, he looked about him, she wrote, and none of it was anything she had told him to do. The illusion was mostly visual, but sometimes she felt as if a robe was lightly rubbing against her, and once a hand seemed to touch her shoulder.

A Frenchwoman on horseback in the Himalayas travels with her party, while a small round monk walks beside her and casts no shadow.
He kept pace with them.

Then his face began to change. The features she had imagined in her retreat, the round cheeks and the cheerful look she had picked because they were harmless, gradually altered, she wrote. The fat, chubby-cheeked fellow grew leaner. His face took on a "vaguely mocking, sly, malignant look." He became more troublesome and bold. In brief, she wrote, he escaped her control.

Once, while they were camped, a herdsman came to her with a present of butter. He saw the tulpa in her tent, and he took it, she wrote, for a live lama. In the passage she gives, the herdsman is the one outsider she names as seeing the monk.

She wrote that she ought perhaps to have let the thing follow its course. But the companion had begun, as she put it, to prove trying to her nerves; it had turned into a "day-nightmare." She was also beginning to plan her journey to Lhasa and wanted a quiet mind for it, so she set out to dissolve the monk with the same discipline that had made him. "I succeeded," she wrote, "but only after six months of hard struggle. My mind-creature was tenacious of life." Her book does not say exactly when those six months fell.

She did not claim more than she could prove. "There is nothing strange in the fact that I may have created my own hallucination," she wrote. Then she added the other side: "The interesting point is that in these cases of materialization, others see the thought-forms that have been created." In her own story, the herdsman is her example for that second side. She left the two statements next to each other in her book and never chose between them.

Next in Unexplained CasesThe Story of Hareera from Aminiya SchoolUrban Legend · 1 min

Should this become an Enigma video?

0 votes

Comments

Be kind. An editor checks every comment before it appears.

0/1000

    No comments yet. Be the first.

    Read next

    Share this story

    Keep your place in the archive.

    Sign in or create a free account to save stories and submit your own.

    New here? Continuing creates your free account. No password needed.

    Reading, liking and voting are always free.

    One quick check

    Lots of people on your network voted for this story today. Pass this check and your vote counts.